Note: This article contains affiliate links. If you click on these links and make a purchase, we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. This helps support our research and content. Read our full affiliate disclosure here.
Choosing the right side-by-side refrigerator with ice maker changes how you store food and access chilled beverages every day. These refrigerators combine large freezer capacity with a vertically split layout that keeps both fresh food and frozen items within easy reach, and having an integrated ice maker removes the hassle of trays and refilling. You want a model that fits your kitchen, matches how your household shops and cooks, and runs efficiently. This guide shortlists the top side-by-side refrigerators with ice maker across key real-world factors: usable storage layout, temperature control and freshness, reliability and maintenance, and operating cost. Read on for our top picks and the criteria we used to evaluate them.
Top Picks at a Glance
| Best Overall The best all-around choice for most situations | Kenmore 29 cu. ft. Side-by-Side Refrigerator |  |
| Best Quality Built to a higher standard if you want something more solid | Samsung Family Hub Side-by-Side |  |
| Best Value The sweet spot between price and what you get | Forno Salerno 36" Side-by-Side Refrigerator |  |
| Best Budget The cheapest option that still gets the job done reliably | Frigidaire Side-by-Side Refrigerator |  |
| Top Rated A top-rated pick with lots of positive feedback | Samsung Smart Side-by-Side RS28A500 |  |
| Most Popular A crowd favorite that many people choose with confidence | Kenmore 36" Side-by-Side Refrigerator |  |
Kenmore 29 cu. ft. Side-by-Side Refrigerator
| Configuration | Full-Sized Side-by-Side |
|---|---|
| Capacity | 29 cubic feet |
| Freezer Capacity | 10.4 cubic feet |
| Ice Maker Dispensed Type | Cubed |
| Refrigerant | R-600A |
This Kenmore 29 cu. ft. side-by-side refrigerator is built for family kitchens that need generous, organized storage plus a built-in ice and water dispenser. It uses Accela Chill and Accela Freeze to push cold air quickly after adding groceries and a Multi-Flow Air System to keep temperatures consistent across seven glass shelves. The freezer hides a space-saving door-mounted ice maker that produces roughly 3 pounds of ice per day while the external dispenser uses an NSF-certified filter for chilled water and ice. Practical touches include edge-to-edge adjustable shelving, four gallon-size door bins, dual crisper drawers, bright LED lighting, and a quiet inverter compressor. The stainless steel doors are fingerprint resistant which helps keep the exterior looking clean. Important considerations are the large footprint typical of standard-depth side-by-side units and energy consumption listed at 731 kWh/year, so buyers focused on compact fits or top efficiency may want different form factors. Installation is freestanding only and the unit uses R-600A refrigerant.
Best for: Buyers who want a roomy, family-oriented side-by-side refrigerator that balances organized storage, convenient filtered ice and water, and faster cooling performance for everyday household use.
Less Ideal for: Those who need a compact or counter-depth refrigerator for tight kitchen spaces or who prioritize the most energy-efficient models available should consider other options.
- Large 29 cu. ft. total capacity with organized storage features for families
- Accela Chill and Accela Freeze plus Multi-Flow Air System for faster, more even cooling
- Built-in water dispenser and NSF-certified filtered ice with a space-saving door-mounted ice maker
- Adjustable edge-to-edge glass shelves and multiple gallon-size door bins for flexible organization
- Quiet inverter compressor and enhanced LED lighting for visibility and reduced noise
- Ice maker output is modest at about 3 lbs per day compared with larger dedicated ice machines
- Higher annual energy consumption at 731 kWh/year compared with more efficient models
Verdict: Choose this Kenmore if you want a large, well-organized side-by-side with built-in filtered ice and fast cooling for everyday family use.
Samsung Family Hub Side-by-Side
| Capacity | 26.7 cubic feet |
|---|---|
| Freezer Capacity | 9.5 cubic feet |
| Configuration | Side-by-Side |
| Water Dispenser Type | Filtered cold water |
| Compressor Type | rotary_scroll |
This Samsung Family Hub side-by-side refrigerator pairs a large 26.7 cu ft capacity with a touchscreen Family Hub that centralizes calendars, notes, and smart-home access on the door. It delivers even cooling across shelves using multi-vent airflow and a rotary scroll compressor designed for steady temperature control, while the interior high-capacity icemaker and external filtered water dispenser make drink prep convenient without opening doors. The flat panel, fingerprint-resistant stainless steel finish keeps the exterior low-maintenance and the recessed handles give a built-in look. Practical downsides to consider are the footprint and weight typical of full-size side-by-side units, and the reliance on smart features for full value if you do not use app or voice integrations. Installation is freestanding and the unit meets ENERGY STAR Emerging Technology standards, so it balances performance with reasonable energy use for a premium refrigerator.
Best for: Buyers who prioritize steady cooling performance, large internal storage, and built-in ice and water along with smart-home integration for kitchens that serve as a household command center.
Less Ideal for: People who need a compact or lightweight fridge solution or who prefer a minimalist appliance without touchscreen or app features.
- Large 26.7 cu ft capacity with separate fresh food and freezer sections
- Built-in Family Hub touchscreen for calendars, notes, and smart-home control
- High-capacity indoor icemaker plus external filtered water dispenser
- All-around cooling with multi-vent airflow for more even shelf temperatures
- ENERGY STAR Emerging Technology recognition for improved energy performance
- Large physical footprint and heavy weight may complicate delivery and placement
- Smart features add complexity and deliver less value if you do not use connected functions
Verdict: Choose this Samsung if you want a performance-focused side-by-side with a high-capacity icemaker and smart Family Hub features for an integrated kitchen experience.
Forno Salerno 36" Side-by-Side Refrigerator
| Capacity | 20 cubic feet |
|---|---|
| Voltage | 115 volts |
| Cooling Method | Compressor |
| Refrigerant | R-600A |
| Defrost System Type | Automatic |
The Forno Salerno 36" side-by-side is a built-for-kitchen refrigerator that combines a frost-free cooling system, inverter compressor, and an integrated ice maker with an LED touch control panel. It is typically used as a primary family fridge where organized storage and easy access to frozen goods matter; the layout includes adjustable glass shelves, multiple door bins, two pull-out freezer drawers and a dedicated freezer section. The inverter compressor and multi-airflow cooling aim to keep temperatures consistent while using less energy, and the child-lock and digital controls simplify daily adjustments. Practical features such as spill-proof glass shelves, an external water and ice dispenser, and a door-ajar alarm make routine use straightforward. Expect a large footprint and the need to confirm counter-depth fit; given its size and heavier weight, installation and delivery planning are important. The freezer and refrigerator capacities are split for family storage, but buyers wanting the largest single fresh-food volume may prefer different layouts.
Best for: Buyers who prioritize a practical, feature-rich primary refrigerator with reliable cooling, organized storage, and an integrated ice maker for everyday family use.
Less Ideal for: Anyone with a small kitchen, limited doorway access, or who needs a compact or ultra-counter-depth refrigerator should consider smaller or different form factors.
- Integrated ice maker and external water/ice dispenser for convenient beverage access
- Inverter compressor with multi-airflow cooling for steadier temperatures and improved efficiency
- Frost-free design and automatic defrost reduce maintenance
- Adjustable glass shelves and multiple door bins allow flexible organization
- Child lock and LED touch controls for simple, safe operation
- Large overall dimensions require measuring for proper kitchen fit
- Heavier weight increases complexity of delivery and placement
Verdict: Choose the Forno Salerno 36" if you want a practical, well-equipped side-by-side with an ice maker and steady, efficient cooling for everyday family use.
Frigidaire Side-by-Side Refrigerator
| Configuration | Side-by-Side |
|---|---|
| Capacity | 22.2 cubic feet |
| Defrost System Type | Automatic |
| Voltage | 120 volts |
| Refrigerant | R-600A |
This Frigidaire side-by-side refrigerator is a straightforward, budget-friendly model that packs a 22.2 cubic foot capacity, automatic defrost, LED interior lighting, and a built-in ice maker into a 33-inch-wide freestanding design. It uses a compressor cooling system with wire shelving and reversible doors to fit common kitchen layouts, and the electronic lock and air filter add convenience for everyday use. Practical benefits include a clear separation between fridge and freezer sections for easy organization and a matte stainless appearance that resists flashy styling. Expect typical energy use for its class, with the listing showing higher annual consumption than more efficient models, and wire shelves can be less flexible than adjustable glass shelving. Installation is simple for standard freestanding setups but buyers with tight alcoves should confirm clearance because dimensions are larger than compact units. For shoppers prioritizing straightforward functionality and an included ice maker without premium features, this unit delivers reliable basics at an accessible level.
Best for: Buyers looking for an affordable, no-frills side-by-side refrigerator with an integrated ice maker who prioritize straightforward functionality over premium energy efficiency or high-end finishes.
Less Ideal for: Shoppers who want the lowest possible energy use, the quietest compressor technology, or premium adjustable glass shelving should consider higher-end or more efficient alternatives.
- Included ice maker and electronic lock for convenience and security
- Reversible doors and freestanding design simplify placement during installation
- LED interior lighting and air filter improve visibility and odor control
- Compressor cooling with separate fridge and freezer sections aids organization
- Annual energy consumption is relatively high compared with more efficient models
- Wire shelving offers less flexible storage and a less premium look than glass shelves
Verdict: A practical, budget-focused side-by-side refrigerator that includes an ice maker and basic convenience features for buyers who want reliable function without premium upgrades.
Samsung Smart Side-by-Side RS28A500
| Capacity | 28 cubic feet |
|---|---|
| Freezer Capacity | 10.1 cubic feet |
| Defrost System Type | Automatic |
| Cooling Method | Compressor |
| Refrigerant | R-600A |
This Samsung side-by-side fridge delivers a large, well-organized 28 cubic foot interior with a 10.1 cu ft freezer and in-door ice maker, designed for everyday family use. It uses multivent cooling and a digital inverter compressor to maintain even temperatures across shelves while the automatic defrost and app connectivity give remote alerts and control. The flat-panel stainless finish and recessed handles provide a modern look and a fingerprint-resistant surface that reduces upkeep. Inside you get adjustable shelves, gallon door bins, LED lighting, and smooth-glide freezer drawers that make loading and finding items straightforward. Energy consumption is listed and the compressor carries extended parts coverage, which supports long-term reliability. Trade-offs are its large footprint and weight, which require assuring kitchen clearance and a sturdy delivery path, and its annual energy use that buyers should compare to other efficiency-rated models. For buyers seeking a dependable, feature-rich side-by-side with a built-in ice maker and smart alerts, this model covers the essentials without exotic extras.
Best for: Buyers who prioritize a reliable, full-size refrigerator with a dependable compressor, even cooling, and smart alerts for peace of mind in everyday family use.
Less Ideal for: People looking for a compact unit or who need the absolute lowest-energy model should consider smaller or higher-efficiency alternatives.
- Large 28 cu ft capacity with dedicated fresh and freezer sections for organized storage
- Built-in in-door ice maker and smooth-glide freezer drawers for convenient frozen food access
- Wi-Fi connectivity and digital controls provide remote alerts and easy temperature adjustments
- Fingerprint-resistant stainless finish and recessed handles reduce visible wear and simplify cleaning
- Large physical footprint and substantial weight require planning for delivery and installation
- Annual energy consumption is relatively high and should be compared if efficiency is a priority
Verdict: A roomy, smart side-by-side with a proven compressor and built-in ice maker that focuses on dependable cooling and convenient daily use.
Kenmore 36" Side-by-Side Refrigerator
| Capacity | 20 cubic feet |
|---|---|
| Freezer Capacity | 6.5 cubic feet |
| Configuration | Side-by-Side |
| Ice Maker Type | Cubed |
| Voltage | 115 volts |
This Kenmore 36" side-by-side refrigerator is built for buyers who want a space-conscious, feature-packed unit with an integrated ice and water dispenser. The counter-depth design keeps the exterior flush with cabinetry while the 20 cu. ft. total capacity and edge-to-edge glass shelves let you organize groceries and party trays without wasted space. Accela Chill and a multi-flow air system help rapidly cool new items and maintain even temperatures across shelves, and the factory-installed filter provides cold water plus cubed ice from the exterior dispenser. The inverter compressor is designed for quieter, more efficient operation, and bright LED lighting makes interior organization easier. Practical downsides to note are the moderate 20 cu. ft. size for larger families and the unit's higher annual energy use compared with the most efficient modern models, so it is best where counter-depth styling and built-in dispensers are priorities rather than maximum capacity or the lowest possible running cost.
Best for: Buyers who prioritize a counter-depth, built-in look with convenient external ice and water dispensing and who value practical features that simplify everyday use.
Less Ideal for: Households that regularly need larger refrigeration volume or want the absolute lowest ongoing energy cost should consider larger or more efficient alternatives.
- Counter-depth design for a built-in look without custom cabinetry
- Built-in external water and ice dispenser with factory-installed filter
- Inverter compressor and ENERGY STAR certification for quieter, more efficient cooling
- Edge-to-edge tempered glass shelves provide flexible, spill-proof storage
- Multi-flow air system and Accela Chill help maintain consistent temperatures
- 20 cu. ft. total capacity may be tight for larger households
- Annual energy consumption is relatively high compared with top-tier efficient models
Verdict: Choose this Kenmore if you want a counter-depth side-by-side with a built-in ice and water dispenser and reliable, energy-conscious inverter cooling in a mid-size footprint.
Choosing the Right Side-by-Side Refrigerator with Ice Maker: Key Factors to Consider
Interior Layout and Shelf Flexibility
The way shelves, door bins, and drawers arrange inside a side-by-side refrigerator determines how usable the stated capacity actually is. Adjustable shelves, slide-out bins, and convertible door bins let you fit tall pitchers, party platters, and oddly shaped containers without blocking airflow.
Look for breakaway or cantilever shelving and options to relocate gallon-size door bins. These features make everyday loading and unloading faster and let you adapt the interior to different grocery trips, which matters more in the long run than raw cubic feet numbers.
Ice Maker Capacity and Access
An integrated ice maker should produce enough cubes to meet household demand and store them without clumping. Consider both daily production rate and the size of the ice bin. Faster production is useful for parties, while a larger storage bin reduces the frequency of run-out during heavy use.
Also evaluate how you access and clean the ice compartment. Removable bins and clearly routed water lines make maintenance and occasional sanitizing easier, which helps prevent odors and ice contamination over time.
Temperature Control and Zoning
Consistent temperature across shelves and drawers preserves freshness and prevents hidden spoilage. Multi-zone temperature control, separate crispers with humidity adjustment, and even air distribution between the fresh and frozen sides reduce food waste.
Digital controls and precise thermostats let you fine-tune settings for different seasons or storage tasks. Models with faster recovery after door openings are better for busy kitchens where doors are opened frequently.
Energy Efficiency and Operating Cost
A side-by-side refrigerator runs 24 hours a day, so small differences in efficiency add up. Look for energy-efficient compressors, good cabinet insulation, and thoughtful layout that minimizes cold-air loss when doors open.
Energy-efficient units typically cost less to run and generate less waste heat in the kitchen. Also consider features that reduce defrost frequency and improve sealed-system reliability, since those reduce short-term repair risk and long-term operating cost.
Door Seals, Construction, and Serviceability
Durable door seals and a solid hinge system keep cold air in and reduce compressor workload. Easy-to-replace gaskets, accessible water filters, and service panels make routine upkeep and repairs less expensive and less disruptive.
Evaluate how panels and components come off for service, and whether common wear parts like water filters are user-replaceable. A design that simplifies maintenance will save time and frustration over the life of the refrigerator.
Installation Fit and Kitchen Integration
Side-by-side refrigerators can be tall and deep, so precise measuring for width, depth with doors open, and ceiling clearance is critical. Consider proximity to plumbing for the ice maker and whether the door swing will interfere with cabinetry or appliance adjacency.
Also check leveling and floor requirements; some units need a solid, level surface and room for air intake on the back or sides. Planning ahead reduces the chance of costly returns or awkward repositioning during delivery and setup.
Space Planning and Measuring for Installation
Measure twice before you buy. Account for the refrigerator width plus at least an inch on each side for clearance, the depth with doors open, and the full height including hinges. If the unit sits between cabinets, confirm the doors can swing fully without hitting trim or adjacent appliances.
Plan for plumbing and electrical access for the ice maker. The water line should be routed with a shutoff valve within reach to aid maintenance, and the electrical outlet should be on a dedicated circuit if local codes require it.
- Check door swing clearance for both fresh and freezer sides
- Measure depth including handles and required air gap
- Confirm water line routing and shutoff location
Managing Food Organization in a Vertical Layout
Side-by-side refrigerators offer tall, narrow compartments that change how you organize groceries. Use door bins for condiments and smaller items, while placing prepared meals on middle shelves where temperature is most stable.
Designate drawers for produce and deli to keep flavors isolated. Consider using clear bins or organizers to keep smaller items visible and prevent forgotten leftovers.
- Store dairy and frequently used items at eye level
- Keep raw meat on the lowest shelf inside the fresh side to prevent drips
- Use humidity-controlled drawers for different types of produce
Ice Quality and Hygiene Practices
Ice can carry flavors and odors from the freezer, so routine cleaning of the ice bin and occasional sanitizing of the ice maker components helps maintain neutral-tasting cubes. Replace water filters on the recommended schedule to avoid off-tasting ice and reduced flow to the ice maker.
If you rarely use the ice maker, consider turning it off and removing standing ice to prevent clumping and stale tastes. For heavy users, keep an eye on ice buildup around the dispenser area and clear it promptly to avoid jams.
- Sanitize ice bin and dispenser chute every few months
- Replace inline water filter at manufacturer-recommended intervals
- Flush water line after long absences to clear stagnant water
Noise, Placement, and Kitchen Comfort
Side-by-side refrigerators house larger compressors and ice-making mechanisms that can generate noticeable noise, especially during harvest cycles. If the appliance sits near a living area or an open-plan kitchen, check noise ratings and consider placement that buffers sound.
Leave space behind the refrigerator for airflow to improve cooling efficiency and reduce fan noise. Anti-vibration pads or a level, solid floor surface will minimize rumble and rattles caused by compressor operation.
- Position unit away from bedrooms or quiet zones when possible
- Allow manufacturer-recommended clearance behind the unit
- Use leveling feet to reduce vibration noise
Water Line and Ice Maker Maintenance Tips
Protect the water line with an accessible shutoff valve and consider using a braided stainless-steel supply line to reduce the chance of leaks. Inspect connections periodically and replace lines that show wear or hard kinking.
Keep a small maintenance log for filter changes and periodic filter-freeze cycles to confirm the ice maker is producing properly. Regular checks prevent mineral buildup and maintain steady ice output.
- Install a shutoff valve near the refrigerator water connection
- Use quality supply lines and inspect annually
- Keep track of filter change dates to maintain water quality
How We Chose the Best Side-by-Side Refrigerator with Ice Maker
We focused on attributes that matter most to people buying a side-by-side refrigerator with ice maker. Primary evaluation criteria included usable storage layout, because the vertical split and shelf configuration determine how easily you store tall items and organize groceries. Temperature control and freshness features were assessed for their ability to protect perishable food and reduce spoilage. We judged ice maker performance and reliability separately, looking at production speed, storage capacity, and ease of maintenance. Energy efficiency and daily operating cost were included because long-term electricity use is a major ownership expense. We checked available temperature zoning, humidity-managed crispers, and the presence of features that reduce frosting or frequent defrost cycles. Finally, we considered build quality and practicality of maintenance, such as door seal accessibility and ease of replacing common wear items. We excluded specialty configurations not matching a side-by-side layout, refrigerators without integrated ice makers, and compact or undercounter units. The final list highlights models that balance interior organization, consistent cooling, dependable ice production, and manageable operating cost.
Our full evaluation process is outlined in our review methodology.
FAQ
How much clearance do I need for a side-by-side refrigerator with ice maker?
You need clearance for ventilation, door swing, and water line access. Allow at least an inch on each side and additional depth for doors to open fully. Also reserve space behind the unit for airflow and the water connection.
Can I install the ice maker myself?
Many owners can install the water line with basic plumbing skills, but follow local codes and manufacturer instructions. If you are unsure about connections or the required shutoff valve, hire a qualified technician to avoid leaks.
Why does the ice taste or smell odd sometimes?
Off-tasting ice usually comes from contaminated water lines, an overdue filter change, or odors seeping from nearby frozen foods. Cleaning the ice bin, replacing the water filter, and flushing the line typically resolves the issue.
How can I reduce frost or ice buildup in the freezer side?
Keep door seals clean and undamaged, avoid leaving doors open, and do not store hot items uncovered. If frost forms repeatedly, inspect the gasket for gaps and confirm the temperature control is set correctly.
Will a side-by-side with an ice maker use more energy?
An ice maker adds some energy use because it cycles water and the ice-dispensing system can require additional fan or heater operation. Differences are modest if the unit has efficient components and a well-insulated cabinet.
Final Verdict
Picking the right side-by-side refrigerator with ice maker comes down to matching interior layout and ice production to your daily routines. Prioritize usable shelving and door-bin flexibility if you store tall or oddly shaped items, and weigh ice maker capacity against how often you host or entertain. Also balance energy efficiency and serviceability, since lower operating costs and easier maintenance reduce long-term frustration. Use the evaluation criteria in this guide to compare specific models and choose the configuration that fits your kitchen dimensions and household habits with confidence.